Old Time Candy Reviews

I got this for my dad’s birthday because he has a bit of a sweet tooth, especially when he’s watching TV after dinner. The candy itself was fun and he seemed to enjoy it, so no complaints there. I just thought the box looked a little plain for something I was giving as a gift, so I ended up putting it in a nicer bag with some tissue paper. Overall, it was okay, just not quite as gift-ready as I expected

I was putting together an order full of old favorite candies and got a quick message that one of the ones I picked was out of stock. I figured that might hold things up, but they suggested a substitute right away and it ended up being a good choice. When the box arrived, it still had all the nostalgic stuff I was excited about, so I was happy. The whole thing was simple, friendly, and easy from start to finish.

I picked up some old-school candy here and the prices were better than I expected. Let’s just say it didn’t feel like I overpaid for a little trip down memory lane

I’m sure I’ll be buying from them again. Everything went well, at least from my experience

It showed up quick, so I’ll give them that, but the tracking was annoying. It didn’t update when it should have, and that’s on them. I shouldn’t have to sit around guessing where my package is

I had no problem at all checking out on oldtimecandy.com. The cart was really easy to update, and my payment went through fast. I also liked that the shipping options were nice and clear before I paid. Overall, it was a really smooth experience and I didn’t have to mess around with the site like I have on some others.

Overall, Trust seems okay and the order eventually showed up, but shipping was slower than I expected. I kind of regret not keeping a closer eye on the order details and timeline from the start. If you buy from them, I’d just recommend checking everything carefully and being prepared to wait a bit.

I wasn’t really planning on making a whole thing out of it, but I ended up ordering one of the 80s decade boxes from oldtimecandy.com after going down a random nostalgia rabbit hole one night. The box showed up in good shape, everything was packed nicely, and I spent more time than I expected just looking through the candy before even eating any of it.

Some of it was stuff I hadn’t thought about in years, and a few pieces weren’t exactly my favorites, but that almost made it feel more like the real childhood candy experience. By the time I got through the box, I realized I’d actually had a lot of fun with it and would probably order another decade box again.

Bags were big. Portions too. No complaints

The candy tasted really fresh and not stale at all. It reminded me of buying it years ago and I was happy with it.

I really appreciated how they kept me updated about my order and shipping the whole time. I kept thinking, okay, good, I don’t have to wonder where this is or if it’s actually moving. The candy showed up just fine too, so no complaints there. I’d definitely order again.

I ordered a candy gift box from oldtimecandy.com for my dad, and the candy itself was totally fine. The problem was the way it was presented. Since it was already picked out and shipped, I kind of felt trapped with it once it arrived.

The box looked plain and not as gift-like as I expected. A few of the candies had shifted around inside too, so when he opened it, it didn’t have that full, nicely arranged look you hope for with a gift box.

For the price, I really thought it would be packed better or feel a little more special. It wasn’t awful, but I was disappointed because it was supposed to be a nice gift, and I didn’t really have time to fix it or replace it.

The shipping cost really wasn’t bad at all. It felt fair, and that made the whole purchase feel a little easier to justify

I was able to find the candy I wanted really quickly, and the whole process was smooth with no hassle. Nice and easy, which I definitely appreciate.

I got a personalized candy box for my dad, and I wasn’t totally sure how it would turn out, but it ended up being really cute. Picking the candies was easy, and adding a little message made it feel extra personal

In my experience, my order from Old Time Candy arrived in really good shape. The box felt sturdy, and none of the candy was crushed or smashed, which I was a little worried about.

I thought everything inside was packed neatly, and the smaller pieces didn’t end up scattered all over the place. It’s a simple thing, but to me it made the whole order feel cared for. 5 stars from me.

I started out just browsing and got kind of sidetracked looking through everything, because there were a lot of candies I remembered from when I was younger mixed in with some I didn’t recognize at all. I kept changing my mind a few times before actually picking anything. Overall, it was a good mix, just way more choices than I expected.

I did end up getting exactly what I ordered, so no complaints there. Everything was correct when it arrived. I just wish the communication had been a little clearer along the way because I was left wondering what was going on a couple of times, which was kind of annoying.

I ordered this candy box expecting it to match the description, but a few of the items were different from what was listed. It wasn’t a huge deal, but if you’re buying it for specific candies, it’s definitely a little frustrating. The box was still fine overall, but they really should keep the product info updated so people know what they’re getting

Honestly... I was so surprised they had some old candies I seriously haven’t been able to find anywhere near me!!! I ordered a few things I remembered from when I was a kid, and everything showed up just fine. The site was easy to use too!! Really happy I stumbled across this place!!!